A second opinion on kundli matching

You were told no.

See how five documented methods read the same charts.

We compare your two charts across five documented kundli-matching traditions and show where they agree, disagree, and why. Whether you have a previous verdict or are starting here, get the reasoning in one astrologer-reviewed report.

Get your second opinion — ₹999Digital report only · checked by an astrologer before deliveryOr read a complete sample report first — free, no email.
  • Fixed price
  • No remedies
  • Astrologer reviewed
  • Privacy first

A situation you may recognise

The match was moving forward. Then the kundli became a question.

A couple sitting at a kitchen table, looking down at papers spread between them

Perhaps you have been together for years. Your parents came around. Somebody said let’s just get the kundlis checked — a formality, the last box before anyone talks about dates.

Then a reading of two charts, and the word no.

The difficult part may be not knowing what led to that answer.A score or an unfamiliar term is hard to discuss without the reasoning behind it. When someone in your family trusts that reading, a clear explanation gives you something specific to understand together.

Her mum was fully on our side before this. But since yesterday, after the kundali reading, even she has changed.
From our reading of 93 public discussions about disputed kundli results — not a customer, and not a review

This is for you if…

One honest note before you read on. We are not here to tell you the astrologer was wrong, and we are not here to talk anyone out of anything they believe. Sometimes all five methodologies agree with the answer you were given. When that happens we say so, plainly, on the first page.

Which situation brought you here?

We were told the match is badAnd you want a second opinion before anyone decides.See the example Two astrologers gave different answersConflicting advice has left you confused.Compare the rules Our families follow different traditionsNorth versus South — two different methodologies.See the five methods Nobody has read our charts yetSee all five readings first, before anyone else weighs in.See the five methods

The thing nobody tells you

Kundli matching has different methods. We compare five.

Different regions of India use different tables, different rule sets and different cut-offs. A family in Punjab and a family in Tamil Nadu are not necessarily applying the same rules. Regional practices draw on different authorities and conventions.

The North Indian methodology — Ashtakoota, literally the eight kootas — scores eight kootas, things being compared, out of 36 points. Southern porutham-based methods use ten poruthams, or compatibility tests, and different acceptance rules. The published approaches also differ in how they judge Mars.

A useful second opinion names the method, shows its working, and explains whether another documented approach changes the finding.

Get your second opinion — ₹999

A score tells you what one methodology concluded.
It does not tell you how robust that conclusion is.

Three comparisons follow, computed across possible pairings or a simulated chart corpus. They show how rules differ, not whether astrology predicts marriage outcomes.

Proof · one

The same chart can be manglik under one rule set and not another.

Mangal dosha is the traditional finding when Mars sits in certain houses, measured from specified reference points. Compare the house lists below; the rates use the same simulated charts under each full profile.

North Indian diamond chart, Mars in house 2123456789101112LAGNAमंMa

Manglik.

Mars sits in house 2 in this chart and does not move. All that changes in this simplified illustration is the house list. The rates also include each profile’s reference-point rules.

Different rules can explain different findings. The North Indian list omits the 2nd house; the South Indian list omits the 1st. They descend from two different verses in two different classical texts. And the lists are only half of it — North judges Mars from the ascendant alone, while South judges it from the Moon and Venus as well. Two documented differences, not one. On the same 2,000 charts, North flags 30.6% and South flags 58.3%.

A different documented rule set may change your Manglik finding. We check which rules apply to your chart and explain any difference. The simulated disagreement rate is not the probability that your own finding will change.

Get your second opinion — ₹999

Proof · two

The number you were given, in context.

You were told a score out of 36. You were probably not told what a normal score is. We computed it across all 11,664 ordered nakshatra-pada pairings — every combination of birth star and quarter the comparison model contains, not a sample. Every pairing is weighted equally: this is a uniform mathematical baseline, not a measured distribution of real couples.

0the average score of all pairings
0of all pairings reach 28 out of 36
0of all pairings reach 30 out of 36

If your family is holding out for 30 or more, they are waiting for something fewer than 3 in 100 pairings can produce. If you were told 20 and it sounded like failure — the model’s average is about 20.1. That is numerical context, not a prediction of marriage outcomes.

The doshas that end conversations are not rare either:

And how sure is it?

Sometimes three minutes matter. Sometimes thirty do not.

A small difference in the recorded birth time changes some tested findings and leaves others unchanged. This illustrative couple’s comparison checks both birth times shifted together, at one-minute intervals. Your report describes its own sampled checks.

No tested change in this window

The question is not only what score you were given. It is how robust that conclusion actually is — and whether anyone told you.

Proof · three

We ran all 11,664 pairings through our comparison checks. 56.4% trigger a tested difference or veto.

This combines score-threshold differences, cancellation effects, a regional-system comparison and veto flags. A veto can be present even when methods agree.

It is not a five-school final-verdict disagreement rate or a survey of couples. The checks overlap; this combined figure counts each flagged pairing once. Mars is measured separately.

For your charts, the useful question is which rule led to the finding, and whether another documented approach changes it.

Same charts. Different rule sets.

The lower score is the one that accepts. The two methodologies are not measuring the same thing.

We are not telling you your astrologer was wrong.

A different conclusion does not necessarily mean someone made a mistake. Your astrologer may follow a different documented rule set. Without the working, we cannot judge the original calculation.

Our report compares five methodology profiles on the same astronomical convention and shows where their rules lead to different findings.

This is a written comparison, not a replacement for your family’s judgement or a promise that the earlier answer will change.

We send you the rule IDs and the citations. Share them with your astrologer. If your astrologer disagrees with our reading, we want to hear it — there is an address at the bottom of this page and a person reads it.

The five, named — with who says so and where it is followed.

Each one is a documented methodology profile: its own rule set, its own house set for Mangal dosha, and a named authority behind it. They are not independent of one another — they share the same astronomical inputs and some of the same texts — which is exactly why it matters where they part company.

MethodologyIts authorityWhere it is followed
North IndianK.S. Charak's Elements of Vedic AstrologyNorth Indian matching profile
Drik PanchangPublished Drik Panchang matching conventionsOnline matching reference
Astro-VisionDocumented SoulMate matching conventionsCommercial software profile
South IndianB.V. Raman's MuhurthaSouthern matching profile
KeralaPorutham-led, with Papasamyam weightingKerala

Sun-through-Saturn positions were checked against NASA JPL DE442. Across 2,000 sampled epochs between 1900 and 2100, the largest disagreement we measured was 0.44 arc-seconds. This sampled test does not validate lunar nodes, houses or astrological predictions. All 93 rules in our registry — 82 cancellations, plus the vetoes and scoring variants alongside them — carry an ID and a citation you can check.

A worked example

A bride from Pune. A groom from Chennai. Three methodologies said no. Two said yes.

Her birth star is Ashwini, his is Purva Bhadrapada. They share the same nadi group — which is Nadi dosha, and costs all 8 of its points.

An illustrative case with fictional names and birth records, not a customer story. Here is what the five methodologies computed for the same two charts:

Priya — North Indian diamond chart789101112123456LAGNAVeSuMeJuSaKeMoMaRa
Priya · Pune
Arjun — North Indian diamond chart891011121234567LAGNARaMoSaSuMeMaVeKeJu
Arjun · Chennai
MethodologyScoreVerdict
North Indian17 / 36Not recommended
Drik Panchang17 / 36Not recommended
Astro-Vision16.5 / 36Not recommended
South Indian13.5 / 36Acceptable
Kerala13.5 / 36Acceptable

Read that table again. The two methodologies that scored the match lowest are the two that accepted it.

Why the low scores accept

The South Indian and Kerala methodologies do not decide by the 36 points at all — they decide by the ten poruthams, and this couple passes seven of ten, which those methodologies class as madhyamam: middling, and acceptable. The 36-point score is almost incidental to them.

Mars, judged five ways

He is manglik in three of the five and clean in the other two — because South Indian, Drik Panchang and Kerala judge Mars from the Moon and Venus as well as the rising sign, and North Indian and Astro-Vision do not.

And one stranger still

The Vashya koota — which of the two holds sway over the other — scores 2 out of 2 in three methodologies and 0 out of 2 in the other two. Same charts. The difference is whether the methodology requires the compatibility to run both ways or only one.

What our engine printed for this couple

The two systems reach opposite conclusions. The South Indian schools accept it; the North Indian schools reject it. Ashtakoota scores 17/36 while the ten poruthams score 7/10. This is not a disagreement about a number — the two traditions are not measuring the same things. A cross-regional family will be told yes by one astrologer and no by another, and both will be right about their own system.

19 named rules are cited in that report. You can look up every one.

Get your second opinion — ₹999

Doosri Rai second-opinion report

What is actually in the report

A written report comparing five documented traditions of Vedic kundli matching on two birth charts, naming the rule behind every disagreement.

The printed report

Designed for a calmer family conversation

“A note for the family” — printable on its own.

An older woman reading a printed page at a table, holding it at arm’s length

A marriage decision can involve more than the two people buying the report. Your family may need a clear explanation too. The family note puts the findings in language you can discuss together.

One page is written for the people you choose to share it with — a parent, grandparent or another trusted family member. It is respectful, it cites named classical authorities, it uses the vocabulary their astrologer uses — and it does not argue with them. It sets out what each methodology concludes and leaves the decision with you and your family.

It prints on its own, on one sheet, with no price and no website on it. In our design, it gives you a shared document to discuss; it cannot guarantee agreement.

Get your second opinion — ₹999

Read the entire thing before you pay a rupee.

Not a preview. Not the first two pages. A complete sample report — the Pune and Chennai case above, in full, with every table and every citation.

A report you cannot read before buying is asking you to take its word for what is inside. This one is not — every table and every citation is in the linked sample, and you can judge all of it before you decide.

Read the complete sample reportthe complete report · no email required

Not deciding today?

Send yourself the sample and read it when the house is quiet. One email, the complete report attached, nothing after it.

One email. No list, no sequence, nothing after it. Or just open it here.

No list, no follow-up sequence, no sales email. We will write once, with the report. What we do with an address.

What happens if you do nothing

Another opinion may help. But if you receive only another verdict, without its rules or reasoning, the answers can remain difficult to compare.

Before paying for any further reading, ask which method it uses, what is included, and whether you will receive the reasoning in writing.Our fixed-price report puts five documented methods side by side.

You do not have to decide today. The complete sample is available to read before you choose whether this comparison would help your conversation.

This is not for you if…

How it works

  1. Step 1Tell us what you were told, if anything.Share the previous finding and who gave it, if you have one. No previous reading is required.
  2. Step 2Two sets of birth details.Date, time and place for both people, with their permission. Births in India are currently supported. An unknown birth time can be left blank; time-dependent findings are marked uncertain.
  3. Step 3Receive your reviewed report.After payment confirmation, we compute the report and an astrologer checks it. We aim to deliver within an hour, by email with a private, printable web link. No call or consultation is included.

What this costs

Compare the service, not just the headline price.

A consultation elsewhereCheck the feeAsk about duration, follow-up and whether a written summary is included.
An automated report elsewhereCheck the scopeAsk which methods are compared and whether a person reviews the output.
A written report elsewhereCheck the inclusionsAsk about citations, review, delivery and the total price.
This report₹999five methodologies, every rule named and cited · inclusive of all taxes

And here is what ₹999 gets you

  • A complete written report, five methodologies side by side
  • Every disagreement traced to a named rule and a cited text
  • Base rates — context from possible pairings and sampled charts
  • Birth-time sensitivity, stated rather than hidden
  • The printable page written for your family
  • Checked by an astrologer before delivery — report only, no consultation

₹999

One payment. UPI, GPay, PhonePe, Paytm or card. Digital report only. No subscription, voice call or consultation. Nothing else to buy.

Get your second opinion — ₹999Digital report only · checked by an astrologer before delivery

Secure payment · UPI · Cards · Net banking

What we guarantee

  • We refund our calculation mistakes. If we mishandle the birth details you supplied or our engine errs, you get a full refund. Astronomical validation and its limits are explained below.
  • An astrologer checks it before delivery. Review is included in the report price; no voice call or consultation is included.
  • We aim to deliver within an hour. If your report does not arrive within twelve hours of confirmed payment, you get a full refund.
  • If we cannot explain a disagreement, we hold the report and tell you why. If we still cannot resolve it, we refund you in full.
  • You can request deletion. We delete your stored report and birth details within seven days and confirm by email, subject to the transaction-record and backup exceptions in our privacy policy.

You are paying for clarity, not for a yes.

There are three shapes an answer can take. All three are valid outcomes of the evaluated methods, not predictions of whether your marriage will succeed.

ContestedThe methodologies materially disagree.

We show you exactly where, and which rule caused it.

Broad consensusMost point the same direction.

There may be minor differences, but the direction is clear.

UnanimousAll five evaluated methodologies agree.

Complete agreement across all five — favourable or not.

Check our work.

From a planet's position to a sentence in your report — every step is visible and documented.

  1. 1Astronomical positions

    Sun-through-Saturn positions were checked against NASA JPL DE442: maximum measured difference 0.44 arc-seconds over 2,000 sampled epochs. This does not validate nodes, houses or predictions.

  2. 2Documented methodology

    Five documented methodologies, each applied with its own rules — house sets, koota tables and cancellations — computed on one astronomical convention (Lahiri).

  3. 3A named rule

    Every conclusion is tied to a specific rule with an ID and a citation.

  4. 4The conclusion

    We show how that rule applies to your charts, and what it does and does not mean.

Transparency at every step — so you can verify, not just believe.

Your birth details are personal.
Read the privacy page

You do not have to take our word for any of it.

You can inspect the report, the methods and the cited rules before buying. These show what we deliver and how the comparison is produced.

So here is everything, before you pay:

The complete sample report is published.

The whole report, before you pay.

The method is published.

Which methodologies, whose books, which tables.

Every rule carries an ID and a citation.

Take them to your own astrologer.

We hold reports back

when our engine flags something it cannot explain, and refund in full if we cannot resolve it.

Email support for your report

A person reads questions about delivery, the report or a possible correction. This is not a consultation service.

The worked example demonstrates the product. It is not a customer testimonial.

Questions people ask

Will this change my parents’ minds?

We cannot promise that. The report includes a respectful, printable family note explaining what the evaluated methods conclude, with named sources. It is designed to support a clearer conversation, whether the methods agree or disagree. The decision remains with you and your family.

You were given a verdict. You were not given the reasoning.

Five methodologies. Every disagreement named and cited. A page your family can read. One fixed price.

Get your second opinion — ₹999Digital report only · checked by an astrologer before delivery

Still deciding? Read a complete sample report first.

P.S. — If you take one thing from this page, take this: a matching score describes the rules used to calculate it. It does not establish what your marriage will be like.

P.P.S. — If all five methodologies do agree with the answer you were given, we will tell you that too, on page one, without softening it. That is the only commitment we make whichever way the comparison turns out.